7

Is there a guideline on the use of politeness forms and thanking (in advance) when asking questions? It seems that the FAQ is not explicit on that. Personally I think that such forms are unneccssary here, as they are not constructive.

The background is that I have just edited a post and stripped the "thanks in advance", "best regards", excuses for poor English, etc. Now I realise that I probably went a bit too far? What are your views on this?

  • 2
    Good question. I've seen some of our mods do the same so assumed it's in a guideline somewhere but it would nice to have a reference. – hippietrail Dec 4 '11 at 18:32
6

There's been a discussion on Meta.SO about this for a while, and while there are some conflicting opinions, the general consensus is that these are unnecessary noise and should be removed. I wouldn't go ahead and remove them with impunity from older posts, but would do if I spot them on new questions.

As far as excuses for poor English -- SE sites are collaboratively edited, including questions and answers, and virtually all questions asked are improved after the fact by people having better command on the language, including grammatical, lexical, vocabulary or punctuation errors. So these excuses become obsolete immediately, and should be removed.

From personal observations, the presence of salutations is somewhat correlated to question length and quality. My guess is that the OP tries to "inflate" the question length to look worthy of being answered, while omitting potentially useful information. I think one of our more pressing mid-term goals should be to not only increase the number of questions, but also their quality, by "educating" the users and even being slightly more strict about what kind of questions we want to see here.

You must log in to answer this question.