Both answers match the earlier, too-subjective-to-survive version of the question.
I flagged the first answer as not-an-answer, although admittedly, I felt a bit crummy for doing so, since it was a reasonable answer at the time it was written. My flag was "disputed".
I still feel like something ought to happen to the question/answer mismatch.
I'm just not exactly sure what... (And obviously, this should have been handled at the time the question was originally edited and re-opened.)