I stumbled upon a peculiarity... Considering whether to VtC a question as off-topic, I was presented with the following:
And the link goes to meta.Skeptics.
I confirmed this wasn't just a browser cache issue by reproducing in two browsers.
Although considering the two close votes for the "claims are not widely heard" reason, I have to wonder if this bug is happening to everyone. It is possible that two other Voters just didn't read closely, though...