Skip to main content
replaced http://travel.stackexchange.com/ with https://travel.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bountybounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


ExampleExample:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

replaced http://meta.stackexchange.com/ with https://meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points herehere from March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

deleted 10 characters in body
Source Link
pnuts
  • 28.5k
  • 15
  • 45

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March4March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

I have no particular objection to the withdrawal of a bounty, specially if offered by a mod and even more specially by one who has lost about 30k rep in good causes, but I do rather object to incorrect guidance. Given bounty emboldens both of:

non-refundable

and

All bounties are paid for up front and non-refundable under any circumstances

can we at least have a footnote on that page that mentions there may be very exceptional circumstances in which bounties are refunded?


Example:

Bounty substracted

and then...

Bounty 'refund'

yet bounty award does not show for any Answer to that Q. At present it does not even show any answer though I think there was an attempt at one (that I did not accept as it added nothing of value, IMO). But even if there was an A at one time I am convinced it was not from the bounty awarder (from whose profile I took the image above) and You cannot award a bounty to your own answer anyway.

I have a feint recollection (though it might just be imagination) of a case on SO of something like a bounty being put on a duplicate question that was then merged or deleted and a mod mentioned that they had refunded the bounty accordingly. As mentioned, I have no objection to mods being able so to do. (Or it might have been a bounty, not from OP, put on a Q that the OP had requested be deleted for breach of confidentiality/risking sanctions from employer or such like.)


The current choice of Title is not mine. Although quite well hidden, one of the bullet points here from March 4, 2012 is:

They can (at their discretion) refund and cancel a bounty.

added 248 characters in body
Source Link
pnuts
  • 28.5k
  • 15
  • 45
Loading
edited title
Link
Fiksdal
  • 14.7k
  • 11
  • 28
Loading
Tweeted twitter.com/StackTravel/status/783737988115292162
I want the guidance revised, not information on mod powers.
Source Link
pnuts
  • 28.5k
  • 15
  • 45
Loading
edited title
Link
JonathanReez Mod
  • 81.6k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 33
Loading
added 171 characters in body
Source Link
JonathanReez Mod
  • 81.6k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 33
Loading
added 14 characters in body
Source Link
pnuts
  • 28.5k
  • 15
  • 45
Loading
added 761 characters in body
Source Link
pnuts
  • 28.5k
  • 15
  • 45
Loading
edited tags
Link
pnuts
  • 28.5k
  • 15
  • 45
Loading
Source Link
pnuts
  • 28.5k
  • 15
  • 45
Loading